The North-Korean Nodong missile family
(based on the unknown Soviet R-18 "Scud-D" missile)
 

Norbert Brügge, Germany

Update: 07.03.2010


The riddle of the North-Korean Nodong missile was difficult to decode up to now. Pakistan and Iran use the Nodong to build there similar Ghauri-I and Shahab-3 missiles. In North Korea the Nodong vehicle was used for the first space-rocket Paektusan (Taepo-Dong 1). In the meantime upon base of an extended Nodong have builded North-Korea, Pakistan and Iran their next variants of missiles.
The North-Korean Nodong missile is not related to the Soviet A-4 (R-2) and R-5M (or the Chinese DF-2) rockets. The use of an engine from a Soviet A-4 or R-5M rocket was not probable, because the used fuel can not be Ethyl-Alcohol/LOX. The flame of the burn-up is apparently similarly a Scud missile. The Scud-B uses TM-185 (Hydrocarbons) / AK-27I (73%HNO3 +27%N2O4) as propellant.
The key to the problem was up to now the kind of the engine used for the Nodong. Recently were found further remarkable photos from the Iranian Shahab/Safir-engine. The engine is clearly similar to the Scud-B engine. It is however ~150% larger formed.
With a meanwhile known diameter the rocket of 1.25 m can be valued a diameter for the nozzle of 62 cm. It is very improbable however, that North-Korea independently has developed a Scud similar stronger new engine.



             Nodong       
  Shahab-3         Ghauri-I           Nodong+        Ghauri-II           Ghadr-I          Nodong++         Ghadr-II

Similar is a single engine from the clustered Chinese engine YF-2. The engine YF-2 is used for the DF-3 missile. The propellant is however UDMH/AK-27S !
A single Nodong engine has a thrust of approximately 284 kN (s.l.). That can calculated become with the kind of propellant, the quantity of ~11.151 kg and the burning time of 95 sec (Taepo-Dong 1 launch). The calculated thrust approximately agrees with the thrust of a single engine of the DF-3 missile.
Pakistani Ghauri missile have a quantity of 12.912 tonnes propellant. It is calculated a burning time of 110 sec. Presumably then a Ghauri-II missile is meant. The Iranian Shahab-3M (syn. Ghadr-I) has an equal dimension. The new Iranian Ghadr-II missile is once more longer. It is used as first stage for the Safir IRILV. It is based on a Nodong++ missile, which was used probably as the first stage of the unknown North-Korean Unha-1 SLV.
An other interesting reference for the origin of the Nodong  is a Russian drawing for the manufacture of an engine, whose measurements and outlines equal the Nodong engine. It is probable, that this engine belongs to an unknown Soviet  missile R-18 "Scud-D" , which exactly corresponds to the Nodong missile. Possibly the engine was constructed for the use of UDMH as fuel. These missile was not taken over however in the rocket arsenal of the Soviets, probably however exports to North Korea and Pakistan as well as China.

Meanwhile at first by Novosti Kosmonavtiki published sensational photos of the Chinese first stage
engine YF-2 from the CZ-1 SLV. It is now confirmed that four single engines are combined with its own turbopumps. The shape of the chambers and the nozzles are more similar to the smaller Scud-B engine than to the Nodong/Scud-D engine.

The Nodong engine has greater similarity to the Soviet four-chamber engine Isayev S2.1000 (Burya booster). On the other hand, the turbopump is much more similar to the Scud-B or the YF-2 engine.
There is some evidence that the Nodong engine is not only identical to the Scud-D engine but also similar to the second stage
engine YF-3 from the Chinese CZ-1/DF-4 rocket.


 

  Nodong Shahab-3 Ghauri-I Nodong+ Ghauri-II Ghadr-I Nodong++ Ghadr-II
Length total ~16,0 m ~16,0 m ~16,0 m ~18,6 m ~18,6 m ~17,1 m ~21,8 m ~20,3 m
Length without warhead/guidance ~11,5 m ~11,5 m ~11,5 m ~13,6 m ~13,6 m ~13,6 m ~16,2 m ~16,2 m
Diameter 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m 1,25 m
Propellant

UDMH/AK-27S

Mass propellant (t) 11,151* 11,151 11,151 12,912 12,912 12,912 15,259 15,259
Engine

Isayev n.n. (1)

Thrust s.l. (kN) 283,8 283,8 283,8 283,8 283,8 283,8 283,8 283,8
Thrust vac (kN) 313,8 313,8 313,8 313,8 313,8 313,8 313,8 313,8
Isp s.l. (Ns/kg) 2417 2417 2417 2417 2417 2417 2417 2417
Isp vac (Ns/kg) 2672 2672 2672 2672 2672 2672 2672 2672
Burn time, nominal (sec) 95 95 95 110 110 110 130 130
Total vacuum impulse (MNs) 29,8 29,8 29,8 34,5 34,5 34,5 40,8 40,8

*) F= (M * Isp) / t = (11,151 * 2417) / 95 = 283,8 kN

  Propulsion of the North Korean Nodong missile family



Nozzle of Ghauri missile engine


The Iranian Shahab-3 missile engine


Nodong engine dimensions

     


Rear of Taepo-Dong-1 (Paektusan)
 

Turbine

  North Korean Nodong missile (Soviet R-18 "Scud-D")


This rare photo provided by the “Thai Irrawaddy News Magazine“ on June 24, 2009, shows a Nodong missile at a factory allegedly in Pyongyang which was photographed during a visit by a Myanmar government delegation in 2008.


Recently confiscated North-Korean fuel-container for Iran



Scud-D/Nodong missile on specially TEL in North Korea's streets
The clear similarity to an extended Scud-TEL is a further reference
 for the Soviet origin of the Nodong rocket.
 

 

  

  Pakistani Ghauri-I and Ghauri-II missile


   
Ghauri launch video

      
Stretched Ghauri-II


 

  Iranian Shahab-3 missile


   
Shahab-3 missile launch


Shahab-3 with differently warheads

  

  Shahab-3M (syn. Ghadr-I) missile


   
      Shahab-3M                                                  Ghadr-I ?              

  
Shahab-3M launch video

   
                                                                  The Ghadr-I is about 40 cm longer as Shahab-3M                                                                                             Smaler fins typically

     

 


Kavoshgar in launch position


Sounding rocket Kavoshgar
Launch video